From: RhettandLink

   It’s Good

Review:

Rob L - I think Rhett and Link redeemed themselves with this video. I thought it was original and funny. I think this would have been funnier if you could have got the lounge singer guy to sing something funny, without knowing it. I kept waiting for them to do this, but it never happened. Little bit of a let down, but all in all a good video. My rating “It’s Good”

Rob B - If this is a piece of viral marketing for Alka-Seltzer, then wow. I love viral marketing. If this was not then, Kudos to Rhett and Link. Either way this was an entertaining video. I will not watch it again and again, but it fit the bill for something worth seeing once. “Its Good!!!”

From: LilJPeg

No Good   

Review:

Rob L - While I rated this video as a No Good, that is not entirely true. Parts of the video were good. Such as, the music. Nothing gets my heart pumping faster than the song Maniac. She’s a maniac, maniac for sure. Oh yeah, great song. The soundtrack to rocky was another nice piece of music. I like the fact that you tried to synchronize the animation with the music and fit the two together, but for me it is still just boring. Maybe it is the fact that the video is way to long. You could easily make three shorter videos and they would hold peoples attention more. I think the wire animation and the grid background also make the video a bit boring, but what do I know? I’m just a critic. My rating “No Good”

Rob B - LilJPeg what are you on? This was awful. There was nothing, Nothing, NOTHING, NOTHING!!!!!! good about this video. To quote the movie Billy Madison, “We are all dumber for that” My god, what possible purpose would one have for this? Why, Why do this to us? You can edit music and animation and yet you subject the viewing public to this low quality. Are you some sort of cereal killer prowling on the viewing public, only to kill our hopes of seeing something good? “No Good!!!!”

From: thewinekone

No Good   

Review:

Rob L - Winekone, this video definitely discusses a serious issue. It ranks right up there with the cure for cancer and water powered cars. You talk about how people want you to be in either the geeky or creepy groups. You forgot about the third group, the geeky creeps, of which you are the president. You are such a nerd talking about warlocks. Everyone knows warlocks shoot fire balls and shadow spells, what a geek. So you asked a question, about what the hell people want from you. Well I have an answer. They want you to be entertaining, funny, witty, charming and good looking. You have a lot of work ahead of you, so stop whining and start producing better stuff that we can rip on. My Rating “No Good”

P.S. You suck at your video.

Rob B - So on the post Question Answered, I explain the difference between a geek, nerd and dork. If this guy was ever a geek, he left that world long ago and is now shunned to being a dork, if the dorks would want him. Dorks, if you were to shun him please to be giving me a name for what you call your outcasts. Tony, you are not funny (Note that I did not add “anymore” after funny). You talk about these commenters as your friends, first sign of being a dork. You talk about gaining an ego boost from posting videos, second sign of being a dork. Wow you are a dork. I think I will watch more to study the ways of a dork. This video is “No Good!!!!”

From: GregOdenFan52

No Good   It’s Good

Review:

Rob B - Greg Oden rules. And I find it perfect that he would name his beagle, rated as one of the dumbest dogs of all of the breeds, Charles Barkley McLovin. Now I love Charles Barkley, but sometimes when he talks I question what he is thinking. Way to go Greg, hope the leg is in good condition and hope to see you on the floor getting a lot of time. “Its Good!!!!”

Rob L - I’m so sick of people saying Greg Oden is so great. The guy hasn’t even played a single game for the Blazers yet, so how can you say he “rules”. I’ll withhold my judgment until he proves himself on the court. Second, just to set the Greg Oden cheerleader, Rob B straight, the dog Oden is holding is not a Beagle. It is a Pit Bull puppy. As far as I’m concerned this video is a waste of time. My rating “No Good”

From: vlogbrothers

   It’s Good

Review:

Rob B - Being one who thinks of himself as a geek, and not a nerd, I would have to say in fact, that yes this guy is a nerd. There are three levels to Geekdom/Nerdom. Geeks are people who love science fiction, video games and trivia, but they also have other interests including dating. A nerd is similar but not as popular with the non-geek crowd. Also, besides not being very popular with non-geeks, nerds are socially retarded, and don’t date much but there intelligence is usually higher than that of a geek. Finally. there are dorks, these are neither geeks nor nerds, their intelligence may not be as high and typically they are the shunned geeks and nerds. This guy, besides being manic, is definitely a nerd. Kudos to you and your nerd bravado. “Its Good!!!!”

Rob L - Neeeeerrrrrrrrdddssss. Where is Ogre and the Tri Lambda nerd squad when you need a good laugh. Actually, I thought this guy was rather interesting. His fast talking and odd factoids kept me entertained through the entire video. As nerdy as it may sound, I actually want to see this Star Trek video he is making. My rating “It’s Good”